Carly, a local college student, develops a relationship with Abram, a young Amish man. Their seemingly innocent courtship soon takes a twisted turn when Abram refuses to return home and takes Carly captive so they can be together forever.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| LLeigha SinnottCarly | Carly |
 Sam BullingtonAbram | Abram |
 Courtney GraceJenna | Jenna |
 Samantha BinkerdMona | Mona |
 Nick ClarkWyatt | Wyatt |
 Annette SaundersMartha | Martha |
 Hailey SwartwoutSarah | Sarah |
| DDiane KirbyOfficer Johnson | Officer Johnson |
| ZZoe WiesnerRachel | Rachel |
 Micah Sanders SilvaIsaiah | Isaiah |
| MMatthew EllsworthChosen Preacher | Chosen Preacher |
| BBlaike LewisSean | Sean |
| MMichael Carr Jr.Pierre | Pierre |