Square Deal Sanderson is in pursuit of a horse thief, but someone else shoots the varmint before Sanderson can offer him a "square deal."
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 William S. HartSquare Deal Sanderson | Square Deal Sanderson |
 Ann LittleMary Bransford | Mary Bransford |
 Frank WhitsonAlva Dale | Alva Dale |
 Lloyd BaconBarney Owen aka Bill Bransford | Barney Owen aka Bill Bransford |
 Edwin WallockMaison | Maison |
 Tom O'BrienWilliams (as Thomas O'Brien) | Williams (as Thomas O'Brien) |
 Andrew RobsonJudge Graney | Judge Graney |
 Bob KortmanHired Killer (uncredited) | Hired Killer (uncredited) |