Bailey and Amanda, a lesbian couple, are determined to have a baby and have created the perfect list of sperm donors, ranked by their ideal characteristics. However, every potential donor they select meets an untimely and bizarre death—falling tree branches, fatal spin classes, art installations gone wrong, and even skydiving accidents. Their "celebrity stretch goal" also meets a gruesome fate. As the deaths mount, Bailey and Amanda begin to wonder if their bad luck is just a coincidence, a curse, or something more sinister at play.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| CCat DavisNot listed | Not listed |
 Kimia BehpoorniaNot listed | Not listed |
 Thomas HobsonNot listed | Not listed |
 Parvesh CheenaNot listed | Not listed |
| LLauren BlumenfeldNot listed | Not listed |
| BBenjamin MathesNot listed | Not listed |
| SScott Nuñez-PetermanNot listed | Not listed |
| TTodd HunterNot listed | Not listed |
| HHank JacobsNot listed | Not listed |
 Joaquín NúñezNot listed | Not listed |
| CCody AdelmanNot listed | Not listed |
| KKai ChoyceNot listed | Not listed |
| KKatie Nuñez-PetermanNot listed | Not listed |
| HHenry CruzNot listed | Not listed |
| SSarah MartellaroNot listed | Not listed |
| CChris PapagapitosNot listed | Not listed |