Two filmmakers searching for the perfect documentary subject stumble across a story that even they don't want to believe.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| JJoel PetrieJoel | Joel |
| DDan SchovaersDan | Dan |
| MMili ParksMili | Mili |
 Jyllian PetrieJyllian | Jyllian |
 Ryan TemplemanRyan | Ryan |
| DDave NilsonDet. Russ Barlow | Det. Russ Barlow |
| TTiffany PipkinTiffany | Tiffany |
| JJan WilliamsDr. Margot Philips | Dr. Margot Philips |
| EEric FisherEric | Eric |
| JJim StevensJim | Jim |
| GGage ClineDavid | David |
| JJefferson TemplemanJonah | Jonah |
| NNadija KrompelMissing Girl | Missing Girl |
| DDavid CardonaOff. Martin Williams | Off. Martin Williams |
| CChristina Lyon ClineDispatch | Dispatch |