Jennifer and Meg Swift are two sisters who are very close despite living far apart. Jennifer is in Salt Lake City, running a successful restaurant she started with her late husband and raising her teenaged son Simon, Meg stayed in their hometown of Hazelwood, helping their parents run the local bakery.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kimberly Williams-PaisleyJennifer Swift | Jennifer Swift |
 Mark DeklinEric | Eric |
 Susan YeagleyBarb Hutter | Barb Hutter |
 Kevin NealonUncle Dave | Uncle Dave |
 Keith D. RobinsonJoe | Joe |
 Ashley WilliamsMeg Swift | Meg Swift |
 Jacob BusterSimon | Simon |
 Anna HolbrookDebbie | Debbie |
 Jim ByrnesLuke | Luke |
| LLila ClarkMadzie | Madzie |
 Roberta ValderramaValerie Sanders | Valerie Sanders |
 Logan DonovanAlex Camp | Alex Camp |
 Anna DainesKate | Kate |
 Landry TownsendConnie | Connie |
| JJoseph Scott CampbellBrett | Brett |
 Briana PriceVictoria | Victoria |
 Tito LivasMartin | Martin |
 Jay HunterSteve Crosby | Steve Crosby |
 David L. KingFrank | Frank |
 Cami CarverLydia | Lydia |
 Anne SwardMary Heller | Mary Heller |
| VVirginia FarabeeYoung Meg | Young Meg |
| EElise WilkinsYoung Jennifer | Young Jennifer |
| TThomas CumminsTiny Simon | Tiny Simon |
| MMatt KoenigCharlie | Charlie |
 Yolanda StangeMaryanne (Uncredited) | Maryanne (Uncredited) |