When an unknown assailant viciously murders the participants in a bank robbery and murder case, it could be a case of vigilante justice - that is, if the two cases are connected. That's for the police to decide - and it's a puzzle that becomes more mysterious with each new clue.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Cady McClainJanet DiLorenzo | Janet DiLorenzo |
| MMatthew GalleFrankie DiLorenzo | Frankie DiLorenzo |
 Doris RobertsAnna DiLorenzo | Anna DiLorenzo |
 Cesar RomeroVincenzo DiLorenzo | Vincenzo DiLorenzo |
 Michael SergioSonny Carbone | Sonny Carbone |
 Michael GenetMitchell Jackson | Mitchell Jackson |
 Antonia ReyMrs. Maria Pajarro | Mrs. Maria Pajarro |
 John SpencerDet. Phil Sullivan | Det. Phil Sullivan |
| KKevin GeerDet. Ed Warren | Det. Ed Warren |
 Priscilla LopezDr. Gail Gitterman | Dr. Gail Gitterman |
 Bingo O'MalleyPriest | Priest |
| DDon BrockettGeorge | George |
 Ru FlynnKatie | Katie |
| AAlex ColemanMr. Dixon | Mr. Dixon |
 David EarlyCaptain | Captain |