Two twins raised Jewish become Christians while attending different colleges, returning home to share the news with mixed reactions.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Eddie MekkaRabbi | Rabbi |
 James J. FuertesSimon | Simon |
 Susannah DevereuxGrandma Mazis | Grandma Mazis |
| RRusty WhitenerBernard | Bernard |
| DDonovan KirkpatrickNot listed | Not listed |
 John Michael MorrisNot listed | Not listed |
 Reen VogelNot listed | Not listed |
| BBrittany MannNot listed | Not listed |
 David DitmoreNot listed | Not listed |
| EElla Rose KleinNot listed | Not listed |
| JJake LevinNot listed | Not listed |
| RReegus FlenoryNot listed | Not listed |
| PParker ArnoldNot listed | Not listed |
| DDenny BrownleeNot listed | Not listed |
| MMarina Barika FaceyNot listed | Not listed |
| AAmy Neely AdkinsNot listed | Not listed |