When the Postables discover an antique vase, they trace it back to three girls who attempted to sell it in to save their family farm. With the farm again facing hardship, the Postables must choose between doing what's legal and what's moral.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Eric MabiusOliver O'Toole | Oliver O'Toole |
 Kristin BoothShane McInerney | Shane McInerney |
 Yan-Kay Crystal LoweRita Haywith | Rita Haywith |
 Geoff GustafsonNorman Dorman | Norman Dorman |
 Gregory HarrisonJoe O'Toole | Joe O'Toole |
 Zak SantiagoRamon Rodriguez | Ramon Rodriguez |
 Barry BostwickBill Haywith | Bill Haywith |
 Colleen CampSunny Haywith | Sunny Haywith |
 Emilie UllerupDale Travers | Dale Travers |
 Kim DelaneyKim | Kim |
 Laura BertramPeggy (30) | Peggy (30) |
 Dakota GuppyPeggy (12) | Peggy (12) |
 Em HaineBunny (24) | Bunny (24) |
 Sienna BohnMary Lou (28) | Mary Lou (28) |
 Chris GauthierIgor | Igor |
 Kyla MatthewsAbby (9) | Abby (9) |
 Ema MlinarMary Lou (11) | Mary Lou (11) |
 Cecilia DeaconBetty (28) | Betty (28) |
| EElizabeth IrvingBetty (13) | Betty (13) |
 Zahf ParooMark Benahan | Mark Benahan |
 Peter BensonMr. Everett | Mr. Everett |
 Stellina RusichRuth | Ruth |
| KKrystle Dos SantosProducer | Producer |
 Andy ThompsonAuctioneer | Auctioneer |