SHIMMER Women Athletes Volume 86 took place in Chicago, Illinois. The event was held on November 11, 2016.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Callee KeatingKellie Skater | Kellie Skater |
 Chantelle AllisonShazza McKenzie | Shazza McKenzie |
 Jamine BenitezMercedes Martinez | Mercedes Martinez |
 Shayna BaszlerNot listed | Not listed |
 Mickie JamesNot listed | Not listed |
 Vanessa KravenNot listed | Not listed |
 Candice LeRaeCandice LeRae | Candice LeRae |
 Dori PrangeHeidi Lovelace | Heidi Lovelace |
 Cheree Georgina CrowleyEvie | Evie |
 Stephanie BellMia Yim | Mia Yim |
 Tessa BlanchardNot listed | Not listed |
 Jessica CricksJessicka Havok | Jessicka Havok |
 Steffanie NewellNixon Newell | Nixon Newell |
 Xandra BaleNot listed | Not listed |
 Ashly MartinezHudson Envy | Hudson Envy |
 Ashley AlfaroShotzi Blackheart | Shotzi Blackheart |
 Melanie CruiseNot listed | Not listed |
 Zoey SkyeAngel Dust | Angel Dust |
 Leva BatesNot listed | Not listed |
 Rhia O'ReillyNot listed | Not listed |
 Kimberly Ann FrankeleKimber Lee | Kimber Lee |
 Kayleigh KerrKay Lee Ray | Kay Lee Ray |
 Lindsay MillerNicole Matthews | Nicole Matthews |