Naughty or Nice inspector Isabel Haynes doesn’t anticipate anything out of the ordinary when she’s assigned to evaluate 11-year-old Charlie Duncan. However, soon, Isabel falls for Charlie’s widowed father Jason, which makes her question the rigid rules of her job. As Christmas approaches, Isabel must choose between following the holiday algorithm or following her heart.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lacey ChabertIsabel Haynes | Isabel Haynes |
 Andrew W. WalkerJason Duncan | Jason Duncan |
 Cadence ComptonCharlie Duncan | Charlie Duncan |
 Steve BacicRudolph Sweitzer | Rudolph Sweitzer |
 Louriza TroncoHeidi | Heidi |
 BJ HarrisonWanda | Wanda |
 Alessandro MiroGiuseppe | Giuseppe |
| DDax BelangerSanta | Santa |
 Francisco Trujillo Avalos-DavidsonJimbo | Jimbo |
 Kurt LongSanta Impersonator | Santa Impersonator |
 Brahm TaylorFred | Fred |
 Antonio CayonneOscar | Oscar |
| CCharlie CherriereFriend | Friend |
| HHayden MarkusTeddy | Teddy |
 Yobdee MarazziSarah | Sarah |
| SShel WymingaVendor / Inspector 089 | Vendor / Inspector 089 |
| EEamon McBrideYoung Kid Sneezes | Young Kid Sneezes |
 Flora KarasDonner | Donner |
| MMadeleine WhiteCookie Girl | Cookie Girl |
| FFelix BurkeEddie | Eddie |
| GGian CarloExcited Boy(as Gian Carlo) | Excited Boy(as Gian Carlo) |
| BBenicio HernandezBoy with Backpack | Boy with Backpack |
 Jenn MacLean-AngusWoman at Bus Stop | Woman at Bus Stop |
| AAnthony T. WillettBare Head Old Man | Bare Head Old Man |
| MMaleki PaquinDelinquent Teenager | Delinquent Teenager |
| JJocelyn WaleSprinting Woman | Sprinting Woman |