"She Made Them Do It" follows the twisted life of Sarah Pender, a charismatic, intelligent young woman who would become one of the country’s most sought after fugitives.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jenna DewanSarah Jo Pender | Sarah Jo Pender |
 Mackenzie PhillipsJamie Long | Jamie Long |
 Steve BacicMarshal Sean Harlan | Marshal Sean Harlan |
 Nels LennarsonScott Spitler | Scott Spitler |
 Greyston HoltRick Hull | Rick Hull |
 Andrew AirlieBob Hopner | Bob Hopner |
 April TelekMimi Lundt | Mimi Lundt |
 Lisa Marie CarukFarrell Lohman | Farrell Lohman |
 Lucie GuestTrish Nordman | Trish Nordman |
 Nneka CroalPaula | Paula |
 C.J. Jackman-ZiganteCorinne | Corinne |
 Rachel HaywardJulia Rogers | Julia Rogers |
 Jesse MossMcCorkle | McCorkle |
 Jerry TrimbleJackson | Jackson |
 Primo AllonDrew | Drew |
 Joanne WilsonBetty | Betty |
 Vincent GaleDetective Murphy | Detective Murphy |
 Dakota GuppyZoe | Zoe |
 Michael St. John SmithFred Cook | Fred Cook |
 John WalshSelf | Self |
 Anthony ShimThin Cop | Thin Cop |
| DDerek MorrisonJerry | Jerry |
 Jaren MooreSally Port Guard | Sally Port Guard |
 Rob MortonBen | Ben |
 Bradley StrykerMan | Man |
 Dean MarshallTucker Shift | Tucker Shift |
| JJarrett KnowlesKid | Kid |
 Xantha RadleyRoxanne | Roxanne |
 Bethany BrownCheryl | Cheryl |
 Nicholas HarrisonTony Brady | Tony Brady |