In true 1950's educational film style we watch as high school boy Johnny wrestles with a terrible secret. Johnny is a closeted-heterosexual. What will his dads do when they discover he's only pretending to be like everyone else.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| KKelly DixonNarrator | Narrator |
| MMickey SmithPaperboy | Paperboy |
| TTanya GingerichFirst Housewife | First Housewife |
| SSara Kathryn BakkerSecond Housewife | Second Housewife |
 John HartmannFirst Dad | First Dad |
| BBlayne PerryFirst Businessman | First Businessman |
| DDuncan RogersSecond Businessman | Second Businessman |
| JJim OakleyFirst Football Player | First Football Player |
| JJ.J. MessinaSecond Football Player | Second Football Player |
| JJordanna DezeeuwEvil Hetero Woman | Evil Hetero Woman |
| PPete BarkerDr. Dinsey | Dr. Dinsey |
| BBill PedenThe Confessor | The Confessor |
| SStephen PalgonJohnny | Johnny |
| MMargot EdlingDiane | Diane |
| BBill ShortSecond Dad | Second Dad |