In a spoof of Siskel and Ebert's Sneak Previews, Telly and Oscar are seen in a movie theater, reviewing the silliest songs from Sesame Street. Telly loves all of them and he gives them 5 "Wows". Oscar, however, dislikes them and gives them 5 "Phooeys" (but ends up liking the last clip).
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Martin P. RobinsonTelly Monster / Monty (voice) | Telly Monster / Monty (voice) |
 Caroll SpinneyOscar the Grouch (voice) | Oscar the Grouch (voice) |
| JJudy SladkyAlice Snuffleupagus (voice) (archive footage) | Alice Snuffleupagus (voice) (archive footage) |
 Annette CaludCelina (archive footage) | Celina (archive footage) |
 Lexine BondocLexine (archive footage) | Lexine (archive footage) |
 Bob McGrathBob Johnson (archive footage) | Bob Johnson (archive footage) |
 David RudmanHumphrey (voice) (archive footage) | Humphrey (voice) (archive footage) |
 Joey MazzarinoIngrid (voice) (archive footage) | Ingrid (voice) (archive footage) |
 Kevin ClashNatasha (voice) (archive footage) | Natasha (voice) (archive footage) |