Caroline and Margo respond to a "Missed Connections" ad on Craigslist, only to realize that there whirlwind romance was a trap, and the man of her dreams is leading a secret life. The Two women join forces to bring down the dangerous con man who simultaneously romanced and duped them.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Elisabeth RöhmCaroline | Caroline |
 Jon PrescottGavin | Gavin |
 Julie MondMargo | Margo |
 Robert MailhouseJason Birch | Jason Birch |
 Jessica AmleeIssie | Issie |
 April AudiaDetective Mickle | Detective Mickle |
 Tanner StineNoah | Noah |
 Rick ChambersReporter | Reporter |
 Holly KaplanJewelry Store Owner | Jewelry Store Owner |