In this third movie about Shiloh, Judd Travers is accused of killing a man he once fought in a bar. Everyone in the town consider Judd to be guilty except Marty Preston, but even him has some doubts. Trying to clear Judd's name Marty and his friend searches the woods to find the criminal.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Scott WilsonJudd Travers | Judd Travers |
 Gerald McRaneyRay Preston | Ray Preston |
 Jason DolleyMarty Preston | Marty Preston |
 Ann DowdLouise Preston | Louise Preston |
 Bonnie BartlettMrs. Wallace | Mrs. Wallace |
 Jordan GarrettDavid Howard | David Howard |
 Kyle ChavarriaDara Lynn Preston | Dara Lynn Preston |
 Taylor MomsenSamantha Wallace | Samantha Wallace |
| LLiberty SmithBecky Preston | Becky Preston |
 Maura KidwellMiss Osborne | Miss Osborne |
| JJudy EspyGrandma Preston | Grandma Preston |
| JJeff DolanSheriff | Sheriff |
| KKari ElyHettie | Hettie |
| AAdrian RiceDoc Collins | Doc Collins |
| JJim DekenCarl (as Jim Diken) | Carl (as Jim Diken) |
 Jilanne KlausDavid's Mom | David's Mom |
 Lawrence ArancioDavid's Dad | David's Dad |
| ZZach ZernaFred | Fred |
| JJ. Michael NashOld Man | Old Man |
 Rachel WinfreeSue | Sue |
| DDonna NorthcottMrs. Niles | Mrs. Niles |
| JJared Sanz-AgeroBad Guy #1 | Bad Guy #1 |
| BBJ AverellBad Guy #2 | Bad Guy #2 |
| JJames AnthonyMan #1 | Man #1 |
| SSusie WallCat Lady | Cat Lady |
| WWilliam BurchNate Fowler | Nate Fowler |
| DDavid WassilakDeputy Pete (as David Wasserman) | Deputy Pete (as David Wasserman) |