After breaking up with her boyfriend, a bookstore manager resists a seemingly perfect guy's attempts to woo her.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lizzy CaplanSarah | Sarah |
 Alison BrieBeth | Beth |
 Martin StarrAndrew | Andrew |
 Mark WebberJonathan | Jonathan |
 Geoffrey ArendKevin | Kevin |
 Melonie DíazIsabelle | Isabelle |
 Timothy BusfieldBenjie | Benjie |
 Gigi BerminghamMom | Mom |
 Grant HarveyTrevor | Trevor |
 Kristin SlaysmanNot listed | Not listed |
 Ray ConchadoSteppenwolf | Steppenwolf |