 John Rhys-DaviesJow | Jow |
 Judd NelsonSeb | Seb |
 Heather MorrisEmily | Emily |
 Jeff FaheyJim | Jim |
 Tony AmendolaFather Estaban | Father Estaban |
 Damian McGintyPat | Pat |
 Pancho MolerAlowishus | Alowishus |
 Gary FarmerSanta | Santa |
 Gavin WhitePushy Boy Dirk | Pushy Boy Dirk |
| RRyan O'MalleyBaby Pat | Baby Pat |
| WWyatt MortensonFred | Fred |
| RRebekah WigginsBar Maid | Bar Maid |
| SScott ClarkPiano Man | Piano Man |
| CCharlene FoxBus Ticket Agent | Bus Ticket Agent |
 Soledad St. HilaireMrs. Ortega | Mrs. Ortega |
 Ryan BegayOfficer Ryan | Officer Ryan |
 Esodie GeigerFBI Agent Martinez | FBI Agent Martinez |
 Elias GallegosFBI Agent 2 | FBI Agent 2 |
| SSylka FelicianoMall Photographer Elf | Mall Photographer Elf |
| AAlli ValdezRestaurant Hostess (as Allison Valdez) | Restaurant Hostess (as Allison Valdez) |
| GGiovanna A. HinojosaFlamenco Dancer (as Giovanna Hinojosa) | Flamenco Dancer (as Giovanna Hinojosa) |
| MMario febresFlamenco Guitarist | Flamenco Guitarist |
 Mike SalazarVincente (as Mike Salazar) | Vincente (as Mike Salazar) |
| RRobbie MarieMaggie | Maggie |
 Otgadahe Whitman-FoxSocial Worker | Social Worker |
| JJavier GonzalesDonations Bucket Bell Ringer (as Mayor Javier Gonzales) | Donations Bucket Bell Ringer (as Mayor Javier Gonzales) |
 Celine R. LopezCleaning Lady (as Celine Rosario Lopez) | Cleaning Lady (as Celine Rosario Lopez) |
| JJuliet Rose SerratoShopper Woman | Shopper Woman |
| SStephen AquilaMall Shopper/FBI Agent (uncredited) | Mall Shopper/FBI Agent (uncredited) |
| SStephen ConnMall Patron (uncredited) | Mall Patron (uncredited) |
