A Manhattan priest with a penchant for solving crimes goes to the aid of a young actress. She is becoming enmeshed in a series of bizarre incidents she can't explain, and her complaints to the police have gone ignored.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Barnard HughesFather Brown | Father Brown |
 Michael McGuireLieutenant Bellamy | Lieutenant Bellamy |
 George HearnMonsignor Kerrigan | Monsignor Kerrigan |
 Robert SchenkkanFather Wembley | Father Wembley |
 David RascheJack Collins | Jack Collins |
 Fred GwynneJudge Potter | Judge Potter |
 Elizabeth WilsonMrs. Glidden | Mrs. Glidden |
 Kay LenzCarol Bain | Carol Bain |
 Peter MaloneyEli Clay | Eli Clay |
 Saul RubinekJerry Stone | Jerry Stone |
 Jeffrey DeMunnWhitney Fowler | Whitney Fowler |
 Donald SymingtonRussell Heyman | Russell Heyman |
| MMaureen SillimanBeth Landau | Beth Landau |
 Alice DrummondGrace Barringer | Grace Barringer |
 Thomas HillCarl Barringer | Carl Barringer |
| SSydney HibbertSteeldrummer | Steeldrummer |
 David RamseyAuction Guest | Auction Guest |
| RRobin Mary ParisAuction Guest #2 | Auction Guest #2 |
| GGary BayerMike | Mike |
 Sudie BondAnnie | Annie |
 Mary BoylanMrs. Blount | Mrs. Blount |
 William DuellPark Keeper | Park Keeper |
| RRichard HughesDeputy Sheriff | Deputy Sheriff |
 David Patrick KellyAudience Member | Audience Member |