 Robert WagnerGilbert Barrows | Gilbert Barrows |
 Dolores HartElinor Harrison | Elinor Harrison |
 Ernie KovacsBugsy G. Foglemeyer aka The Captain | Bugsy G. Foglemeyer aka The Captain |
 Frankie AvalonEns. Rodney J. Foglemeyer | Ens. Rodney J. Foglemeyer |
 Frank GorshinGeorge M. Wilson | George M. Wilson |
 Harvey LembeckNickels | Nickels |
 Sid TomackSammy | Sammy |
 Guy RaymondHelmut | Helmut |
 Buck KartalianFinster | Finster |
 Wilton GraffSimon J. Harrison | Simon J. Harrison |
 Marjorie BennettMrs. Chowder | Mrs. Chowder |
 Carolyn JonesVirginia | Virginia |
 Jesse WhiteMcDonald | McDonald |
| HHal TaggartPilgrim at Turkey Giveaway | Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway |
| HHope SansberryBiddy | Biddy |
 Howard WendellMr. Caldingham (uncredited) | Mr. Caldingham (uncredited) |
| HHal TaggartPilgrim at Turkey Giveaway (uncredited) | Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway (uncredited) |
| TTom SymondsSecond Man (uncredited) | Second Man (uncredited) |
| RRobert StevensonCoast Guard Officer (uncredited) | Coast Guard Officer (uncredited) |
 Cosmo SardoMan in Bank (uncredited) | Man in Bank (uncredited) |
| HHope SansberryBiddy (uncredited) | Biddy (uncredited) |
| BBru MysakNewsboy (uncredited) | Newsboy (uncredited) |
| TTerry HuntingdonYoung Lady Pilgrim (uncredited) | Young Lady Pilgrim (uncredited) |
| GGraeme FergusonFirst Man (uncredited) | First Man (uncredited) |
