When cowboy Nick McCredie notices in a second-hand book an inscription to "Emily, the prettiest girl in school," he writes to her and learns that she is a lonely Eastern farm girl living with her grandmother. Instead of sending his own picture to her, Nick encloses a photo of his handsome friend Pen Walton.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lila LeeEmily | Emily |
 Monte BlueNick McCredie | Nick McCredie |
 Lee ShumwayPen Walton | Pen Walton |
 Manuel R. OjedaPedro | Pedro |
 Ruby LafayetteAunt | Aunt |
 Guy OliverEzry | Ezry |
 Alice KnowlandThe School Mistress | The School Mistress |
 Jim FarleySheridan | Sheridan |
 Charles McHughIrish | Irish |
| DDick La RenoSheriff | Sheriff |
| TTom WalshDan | Dan |
| RRoy MarshallJoe | Joe |