| EEric PospisilYoung Rudolph (voice) | Young Rudolph (voice) |
 Kathleen BarrOlder Rudolph / Twinkle (voice) | Older Rudolph / Twinkle (voice) |
 John GoodmanSanta Claus (voice) | Santa Claus (voice) |
 Whoopi GoldbergStormella (voice) | Stormella (voice) |
 Debbie ReynoldsMrs. Claus / Mitzi / Mrs. Prancer (voice) | Mrs. Claus / Mitzi / Mrs. Prancer (voice) |
 Bob NewhartLeonard (voice) | Leonard (voice) |
 Eric IdleSlyly (voice) | Slyly (voice) |
 Richard SimmonsBoone (voice) | Boone (voice) |
 Alec WillowsDoggle / Prancer (voice) | Doggle / Prancer (voice) |
 Lee TockarRidley / Milo / Vixen (voice) | Ridley / Milo / Vixen (voice) |
 Garry ChalkBlitzen (voice) | Blitzen (voice) |
 Christopher GrayArrow / Donner (voice) | Arrow / Donner (voice) |
 Vanessa MorleyYoung Zoey (voice) | Young Zoey (voice) |
 Myriam SiroisOlder Zoey / Glitter / Schoolroom Doe #1 (voice) | Older Zoey / Glitter / Schoolroom Doe #1 (voice) |
 Elizabeth Carol SavenkoffZoey's Mother / Aurora / Elf Crowd Member #3 (voice) | Zoey's Mother / Aurora / Elf Crowd Member #3 (voice) |
 Cathy WeseluckSparkle / Elf Crowd Member #1 (voice) | Sparkle / Elf Crowd Member #1 (voice) |
 Paul DobsonElf Referee at Games / Dasher (voice) | Elf Referee at Games / Dasher (voice) |
 Colin MurdockComet (voice) | Comet (voice) |
 David KayeCupid (voice) | Cupid (voice) |
| TTerry KlassenDancer (voice) | Dancer (voice) |
| TTyler ThompsonSchoolroom Buck #1 (voice) | Schoolroom Buck #1 (voice) |
 Jim ByrnesElf Crowd Member #2 (voice) | Elf Crowd Member #2 (voice) |
 Matt HillArrow (voice) (uncredited) | Arrow (voice) (uncredited) |
