While Rachel is stuck in a time loop, reliving the night of her parents' Hanukkah party, she leans on the boy her grandmother is trying to set her up with to make it out.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Vic MichaelisRachel | Rachel |
 Bryan GreenbergZach | Zach |
 Rick HoffmanStan | Stan |
 David AttarAdam | Adam |
 David EpsteinJosh | Josh |
 Marnie MahannahSoshana | Soshana |
 Amitai MarmorsteinSeth | Seth |
 Miles MarthallerNoah | Noah |
 Nicole OliverJoanna | Joanna |
 Paula ShawGrandma Rosie | Grandma Rosie |
 Deimon SlaggHarvey | Harvey |
| JJess SmithBex | Bex |
 Morgana WyllieCynthia | Cynthia |
 Jeff GladstoneBusker | Busker |
 Suzanne RisticMildred | Mildred |
 PanouFire captain | Fire captain |
 Kelly BastardYoung Joanna | Young Joanna |
 Tal ShulmanYoung Stan | Young Stan |
 Nicco Del RioAndy | Andy |