A young girl living in Salem attracts the attentions of The Puritan. After he's brushed off by the girl, he becomes furious and desiring revenge, declares to a council of elders that the girl and her mother are witches.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Dorothy WestA Sea Child | A Sea Child |
 Clara T. BracyThe Sea Child's Mother | The Sea Child's Mother |
 Henry B. WalthallThe Trapper | The Trapper |
 George NicholsThe Puritan | The Puritan |
 Claire McDowellNot listed | Not listed |
 Jack PickfordNot listed | Not listed |
 Marion LeonardNot listed | Not listed |
 Gladys EganLittle Child | Little Child |
 Arthur V. JohnsonNot listed | Not listed |
 Alfred PagetIndian | Indian |
 Gertrude RobinsonA Puritan | A Puritan |