Return Engagement was a wrestling event promoted by Ring of Honor. It took place on April 19, 2008 at the Frontier Fieldhouse in Chicago Ridge, Illinois.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Steven HaworthNigel McGuinness | Nigel McGuinness |
 Kevin SteenNot listed | Not listed |
 Adam BirchJoey Matthews | Joey Matthews |
 Colby LopezTyler Black | Tyler Black |
 Zach GowenNot listed | Not listed |
 Jack MillerJack Evans | Jack Evans |
| EEd McGuckinJigsaw | Jigsaw |
 Claude Marrow Jr.Ruckus | Ruckus |
 Rami SebeiEl Generico | El Generico |
 Kota IbushiNot listed | Not listed |
 Patrick MartinAlex Shelley | Alex Shelley |
 Jamin PughJay Briscoe | Jay Briscoe |
 Mark PughMark Briscoe | Mark Briscoe |
 Josh HarterChris Sabin | Chris Sabin |
 Chris SpradlinChris Hero | Chris Hero |
 William Hunter JohnstonDelirious | Delirious |
 Ashley LombergerAshley Lane | Ashley Lane |
 Daizee HazeNot listed | Not listed |
| RRachel FrobelMsChif | MsChif |
 Adam PearceNot listed | Not listed |
| BBrent Alan AlbrightNot listed | Not listed |
| PPelle PrimeauNot listed | Not listed |
 Claudio CastagnoliNot listed | Not listed |
 Dylan Keith SummersNecro Butcher | Necro Butcher |
 Daniel Solwold Jr.Austin Aries | Austin Aries |
 Caleb DewallSilas Young | Silas Young |