At Our Best was a wrestling event promoted by Ring of Honor. It took place on March 13, 2004 at the Rex Plex in Elizabeth, New Jersey.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nuufolau Joel SeanoaSamoa Joe | Samoa Joe |
 Jamin PughJay Briscoe | Jay Briscoe |
 Peter PolacoJustin Credible | Justin Credible |
 Phil BrooksCM Punk | CM Punk |
 Allen JonesAJ Styles | AJ Styles |
 Benjamin WhitmerBJ Whitmer | BJ Whitmer |
 Danny LopezDan Maff | Dan Maff |
 Christopher GuyNot listed | Not listed |
 Scott ColtonColt Cabana | Colt Cabana |
| JJohn StagikasJohn Walters | John Walters |
| BBryan WoermannMatt Stryker | Matt Stryker |
 Steven HaworthNigel McGuinness | Nigel McGuinness |
 Jeremy LynnNot listed | Not listed |
| SSlyck Wagner BrownNot listed | Not listed |
| JJohn BedoyaXavier | Xavier |
 Jonathan FigueroaAmazing Red | Amazing Red |
 Jack MillerJack Evans | Jack Evans |
 James GuffeyJimmy Rave | Jimmy Rave |
 Mark PughMark Briscoe | Mark Briscoe |
 Retesh BhallaSonjay Dutt | Sonjay Dutt |
 Edward Ellsworth AnnisNot listed | Not listed |