 Peter CilellaMichael Danube | Michael Danube |
 Vinny CurranChris Daniels | Chris Daniels |
 Zahn McClarnonCharles | Charles |
 Bill Oberst Jr.Byron | Byron |
 Emily MontagueJennifer Danube | Jennifer Danube |
 Kurt David AndersonBilly | Billy |
| SSkyler MeachamMicah | Micah |
| JJosh HigginsTed Tellensworth | Ted Tellensworth |
| CCarmel BensonSara / Sophie | Sara / Sophie |
 Justin BensonLevel 3 UFO Cult Member | Level 3 UFO Cult Member |
 Aaron MoorheadLevel 2.5 UFO Cult Member | Level 2.5 UFO Cult Member |
 David Lawson Jr.Dave the Level 1 UFO Cult Member | Dave the Level 1 UFO Cult Member |
| GGlen RobertsCharles' Friend 1 | Charles' Friend 1 |
| BBob LowCharles' Friend 2 | Charles' Friend 2 |
 Michael FelkerWhite Trash Kid with Soldering Iron | White Trash Kid with Soldering Iron |
 Thor WixomRoadside Man with Pick Axe | Roadside Man with Pick Axe |
| MMelissa LyonMental Institute Escapee in Window (as Melissa Low) | Mental Institute Escapee in Window (as Melissa Low) |
| SShiblon WixomAntique Store Clerk | Antique Store Clerk |
| MMichael LoschiavoMan with Burned Face | Man with Burned Face |
 Sarah OliverWoman Missing Arm | Woman Missing Arm |
| JJimmy BraylOne-Armed Soldier | One-Armed Soldier |
| MMila RiveraWoman in Photos 1 | Woman in Photos 1 |
| TTabitha BrownWoman in Photos 2 | Woman in Photos 2 |
| CCatherine BurnsThe voice of 'The Tragedy of 1910' (voice) | The voice of 'The Tragedy of 1910' (voice) |
