On Christmas Day, with the help of his grandson, George still haunted with regret from the loss of Violet, the 'wayward girl' he loved decades ago, gets to go back through time and relive and possibly change his unresolved past.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Christopher LloydGeorge Benson (old) | George Benson (old) |
 Teo Rapp-OlssonGeorge Benson (young) | George Benson (young) |
 Amelia DudleyViolet Krue | Violet Krue |
 Andrew BridgesFrank Porter | Frank Porter |
| AAllison FrascaMary Hicks | Mary Hicks |
| RRishon SaltersNicholas Benson | Nicholas Benson |
 Robin S. WalkerFrancie Benson | Francie Benson |
| DDanielle ClavellJanie Benson | Janie Benson |
 Nelson AvidonPeter Benson | Peter Benson |
| SShannon KronstadtMaris Ford | Maris Ford |
| JJennifer JacobsRhonda Tam | Rhonda Tam |
| CCaleigh BarkerBree Kimball | Bree Kimball |
| MMaddox YuBlue Jacket Boy | Blue Jacket Boy |
 Sydney FarleyGreta Lockley | Greta Lockley |
| TTre'von LyleBodie Moore | Bodie Moore |
 Brian DelateMr. Blue | Mr. Blue |