When her father dies, MacKenzie keeps his tradition of the town's fundraising "The Reindeer Games" alive, but when high school crush Chase shows up and plays against her, the spark between them is undeniable.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Sarah DrewMacKenzie Graves | MacKenzie Graves |
 Justin BrueningChase Weston | Chase Weston |
 Brian SillsSimon Cook | Simon Cook |
 Dorian GiordanoJeremy | Jeremy |
| PPaul AmatoRicky | Ricky |
 Tim ProgoshSaul | Saul |
 Ava CheungKit | Kit |
 Puja UppalMeera | Meera |
 Shannon McDonoughTeri Mazze | Teri Mazze |
| AAlicia AlexanderFangirl | Fangirl |
| CCole MundenFirefighter | Firefighter |
| KKen MohabirDude | Dude |
 Ashley BryantWoman | Woman |
| RRichard Patrick Tolton IIKyle | Kyle |
 Vanessa BurnsSerena | Serena |