 Jessica LowndesMia | Mia |
 B.J. BrittAdam | Adam |
 Jessica WalterMrs. Barrington | Mrs. Barrington |
 Justine CotsonasSara | Sara |
 David NaughtonHarry | Harry |
 Juliana DaviesGrace | Grace |
 Dierdre FrielClare | Clare |
 Cheryl FreemanKate | Kate |
 Shannon TyoEmily Chan | Emily Chan |
 Mark FamigliettiJohn | John |
 Jonah CoppolelliRobbie | Robbie |
 Ian LyonsGary Cruise | Gary Cruise |
 Lin HultPenny | Penny |
 Josiah HarveyParty Guest (uncredited) | Party Guest (uncredited) |
 Sarah MinorBoston Shopper / Actress (uncredited) | Boston Shopper / Actress (uncredited) |
 Alex BarberHoliday Market Patron (uncredited) | Holiday Market Patron (uncredited) |
| GGina BarberHoliday Market Patron (uncredited) | Holiday Market Patron (uncredited) |
 David BostonChristmas Party Guest (uncredited) | Christmas Party Guest (uncredited) |
| RRobert GagneChristmas Market Attendee (uncredited) | Christmas Market Attendee (uncredited) |
| HHeidi GarrowParent (uncredited) | Parent (uncredited) |
| CCourtney GonzalezRestaurant Patron / Townsperson (uncredited) | Restaurant Patron / Townsperson (uncredited) |
 Eli D GossKid Talking to Santa (uncredited) | Kid Talking to Santa (uncredited) |
| GGeorge McTyreSanta at Christmas Market (uncredited) | Santa at Christmas Market (uncredited) |
| FFred MletzkoBoston Shopper (uncredited) | Boston Shopper (uncredited) |
| BBill SalvatoreCaroller (uncredited) | Caroller (uncredited) |
