Aurora finds a member of her crime buff group, the Real Murders Club, killed in a manner that eerily resembles the crime the club was about to discuss. As other brutal "copycat" killings follow, Aurora will have to uncover the person behind the terrifying game.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Candace Cameron BureAurora Teagarden | Aurora Teagarden |
 Marilu HennerAida Teagarden | Aida Teagarden |
 Lexa DoigSally Allison | Sally Allison |
 Bruce DawsonJohn Queensland | John Queensland |
 Peter BensonDet. Arthur Smith | Det. Arthur Smith |
 Robin DunneRobin Daniels | Robin Daniels |
 Miranda FrigonDet. Lynn Liggett Smith | Det. Lynn Liggett Smith |
 Jacqueline SamudaMamie | Mamie |
 David IngramMacon Turner | Macon Turner |
 Craig MarchCaptain Fred Burns | Captain Fred Burns |
 Brad HarderOfficer Heard | Officer Heard |
 Julian ChristopherLemaster | Lemaster |