A pair of comic book writers begin to notice scary similarities between the character they created and horrific real-life events.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jesse WilliamsTodd Walkley | Todd Walkley |
 Jordana BrewsterKathy | Kathy |
 Julia KnopeYoung Woman | Young Woman |
 Jay BaruchelEzra | Ezra |
 Niamh WilsonAurora | Aurora |
 Simon NorthwoodThe Man | The Man |
 Isaiah RockcliffeYoung Todd | Young Todd |
 Clark BackoTodd's Mother | Todd's Mother |
 Victoria SnowBorden | Borden |
 Eric OsborneAdam | Adam |
 Nia RoamMegan | Megan |
 Aviva MongilloHannah | Hannah |
 Wade MacNeilGary Reston | Gary Reston |
 Amir Sám NakhjavaniGeneral Store Clerk | General Store Clerk |
 Kyle GatehouseFan | Fan |
 Mark AndradaAwkward Fan | Awkward Fan |
| MMcKale ThompsonSmall Boy | Small Boy |
| CCyrus AazamYoung Man | Young Man |
| PPeter SchoelierHomeless Man | Homeless Man |
| SStacie DunlopSinging Duo | Singing Duo |
| VVanessa Oude-ReimerinkSinging Duo | Singing Duo |
 Chris GleasonBDSM Male | BDSM Male |