Goody Rickby has a child out of wedlock, but it dies when the father, Gillead Wingate, refuses to acknowledge the child or help the mother get medical aid. Wingate becomes one of the foremost figures in the witch hunts, and Goody plots her revenge with Dr. Nicholas, who is really the Devil.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Glenn HunterLord Ravensbane / The Scarecrow | Lord Ravensbane / The Scarecrow |
 Mary AstorRachel | Rachel |
 Osgood PerkinsDr. Nicholas | Dr. Nicholas |
 Maude HillGoody Rickby | Goody Rickby |
| FFrank TweedGillead Wingate | Gillead Wingate |
| DDwight WimanRichard Talbot | Richard Talbot |
 Thomas ChalmersThe Minister | The Minister |