 Matthew SharpeAdam Benson | Adam Benson |
| WWhitney RichardsonNicole Bensen | Nicole Bensen |
| RRussell Sage PatrickRuss Thompson | Russ Thompson |
| BBrax HollowayCharlie O'Connor | Charlie O'Connor |
 Sonia DebreczeniAlaina Fiore | Alaina Fiore |
 Tony WoodCorey Solis | Corey Solis |
| AAmy InsleyDetective Alex Booth | Detective Alex Booth |
 Chaz RiddleDetective Ralph Victor | Detective Ralph Victor |
| LLaura O'NealEthel Sanders | Ethel Sanders |
| PPamela MannFaye Jackson | Faye Jackson |
| KKatina HouseholderBasketball Neighbor /Barbecue Guest /Investigation Onlooker | Basketball Neighbor /Barbecue Guest /Investigation Onlooker |
| MMichael HouseholderBasketball Neighbor | Basketball Neighbor |
| RRandy CrockerDistracted Driver | Distracted Driver |
| RRobert Kyle Jr.Barbecue Neighbor | Barbecue Neighbor |
 David MooreBarbecue Guest /Newspaper Neighbor | Barbecue Guest /Newspaper Neighbor |
| JJillian SiglerBarbecue Guest | Barbecue Guest |
| MMaverick HouseholderBarbecue Guest | Barbecue Guest |
| GGabby CrockerBarbecue Guest | Barbecue Guest |
| LLori MoultonBarbecue Guest 6 /Investigation Onlooker | Barbecue Guest 6 /Investigation Onlooker |
| SStephen NealDog Walker | Dog Walker |
 Lucrecia RodriguezDog Walker | Dog Walker |
| JJack RoyJack walking Dog | Jack walking Dog |
| GGuy AilamNeighborhood Jogger | Neighborhood Jogger |
| TTylan NanceHomeowner Watering Tree | Homeowner Watering Tree |
 Mandy RiveraNeighbor at Mailbox | Neighbor at Mailbox |
| WWendy MungalNeighbor at Mailbox | Neighbor at Mailbox |
| MMathew DodgeInvestigation Onlooker /Live Streamer | Investigation Onlooker /Live Streamer |
| JJackie LuciaGoth Neighbor | Goth Neighbor |
| JJd RobertsJason Reed | Jason Reed |
