New York sportswriter Mack has spent years devising successful hook-up "plays" with her friends, but when she unexpectedly falls for one of her targets, she must learn what it takes to go from simply scoring to playing for keeps.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Gina RodriguezMack | Mack |
 Damon Wayans Jr.Adam | Adam |
 Tom EllisNick Russell | Nick Russell |
 Augustus PrewBrannagan | Brannagan |
 Joel CourtneyRyan 'Little' | Ryan 'Little' |
 Liza KoshyAshley | Ashley |
 Jerry KernionCarl | Carl |
 Ego NwodimClaire | Claire |
 Marin HinkleKirk | Kirk |
| BBrock O'HurnBrady Stratton | Brady Stratton |
 Gina JunVIP Gala Guest | VIP Gala Guest |
 Kais BoukthirSuper Fan | Super Fan |
 Sterling Jonatán WilliamsTattoo Librarian | Tattoo Librarian |
 Darron Jay MorganHoliday Party D.J. | Holiday Party D.J. |
 Dan CordleKirk's Husband | Kirk's Husband |
| CClaudia Maree MailerKourtney Martini | Kourtney Martini |
 George J. VezinaSal Greenberg | Sal Greenberg |
| SScottie DiGiacomoRich woman at Gala | Rich woman at Gala |
 Sarah Dacey CharlesMary | Mary |
| JJames HightowerBartender #2 | Bartender #2 |
 Veraalba SantaWaitress | Waitress |
 Tony FoggiaTicket Taker | Ticket Taker |