Taking off immediately where the last one ended, Mike travels across dimensions and time, fleeing from the Tall Man while trying to find the origins of his enemy and what really happened the night that his brother died. Meanwhile, Reggie battles spheres and the undead in a quest to find Mike before the Tall Man can complete his transformation.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Angus ScrimmThe Tall Man / Dr. Jebediah Morningside | The Tall Man / Dr. Jebediah Morningside |
 A. Michael BaldwinMike | Mike |
 Bill ThornburyJody | Jody |
 Reggie BannisterReggie | Reggie |
 Heidi MarnhoutJennifer 'Jenny' Wheeler | Jennifer 'Jenny' Wheeler |
| BBob IvyDemon Trooper | Demon Trooper |
 Christopher L. StoneMusic & Dwarf Creatures (voice) | Music & Dwarf Creatures (voice) |
| CChloe KayBackground Player | Background Player |
| SSylvia FlammerBackground Player | Background Player |
| DDavid GassterBackground Player | Background Player |
| SSasha KasselBackground Player | Background Player |
| AAidan KasselBackground Player | Background Player |
| EEric Avary13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman | 13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman |
| AAndy John13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman | 13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman |
| GGeorge A. Craig13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman | 13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman |
 Roger Avary13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman | 13th Morningside Volunteer Infantryman |