In this magical tale about the boy who refuses to grow up, Peter Pan and his mischievous fairy sidekick Tinkerbell visit the nursery of Wendy, Michael and John Darling. With a sprinkling of pixie dust, Peter and his new friends fly out the nursery window and over London to Never-Never Land. The children experience many wonderful and exciting adventures with the Lost Boys, Tiger Lily's Indian tribe, and Peter's arch enemy the dastardly pirate Captain Hook.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Mary MartinPeter Pan | Peter Pan |
 Cyril RitchardMr. Darling / Captain Hook | Mr. Darling / Captain Hook |
 Lynn FontanneNarrator | Narrator |
| MMaureen BaileyWendy / Jane | Wendy / Jane |
 Margalo GillmoreMrs. Darling | Mrs. Darling |
 Sondra LeeTiger Lily | Tiger Lily |
 Joe E. MarksSmee | Smee |
| NNorman ShellyNana / Crocodile | Nana / Crocodile |
| JJoey TrentJohn | John |
| KKent FletcherMichael | Michael |
| JJacqueline MayroLiza | Liza |
| EEdmund GaynesSlightly | Slightly |
| BBill SnowdenCurly | Curly |
| CCarson WoodsNibs | Nibs |
| BBenedict HerrmanFirst Twin | First Twin |
 Luke HalpinSecond Twin | Second Twin |
| DDavid KomoroffTootles | Tootles |
| RRichard WyattLion | Lion |
 Joan TewkesburyOstrich | Ostrich |
| PPeggy MaurerWendy Grown-up | Wendy Grown-up |
 John HollandBlack Bill | Black Bill |
| RRobert VanselowStarkey | Starkey |
| RRichard WinterCecco | Cecco |
| GGeorge ZimaKangaroo | Kangaroo |
| FFrank LindsayPirate | Pirate |
| FFrank MarascoPirate | Pirate |
| AArthur PartingtonPirate | Pirate |
| JJim SiscoPirate | Pirate |
| KKirby SmithPirate | Pirate |
| JJohn SmolkoPirate | Pirate |