Flashbacks and flash-forwards illustrate the rise and fall of a love affair between two New Yorkers.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jason RitterPeter | Peter |
 Jess WeixlerVandy | Vandy |
 Jesse L. MartinPaul | Paul |
 Tracie ThomsMarissa | Marissa |
 Noah BeanAndrew | Andrew |
 David RascheAlan | Alan |
| BBobby AielloMale Bartender | Male Bartender |
 Bruce AltmanDad | Dad |
 Dana EskelsonEmma | Emma |
 Kristina KlebeMichelle | Michelle |
 Lawrence Michael LevineMike | Mike |
 Zak OrthKeith | Keith |
 Maryann PlunkettMom | Mom |
 Gregg ProsserWedding Guest | Wedding Guest |