Penn & Teller: Off the Deep End is a two-hour special that premiered on NBC on November 13, 2005. It featured magicians Penn & Teller performing a variety of illusions in various locations around the Caribbean, most of which were done underwater or involved marine animals. It also featured a performance by musician Aaron Carter.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Penn JilletteSelf | Self |
 TellerSelf | Self |
 Daran NorrisAnnouncer (voice) | Announcer (voice) |
 Aaron CarterSelf | Self |
 Ezekiel ZabrowskiSelf | Self |