A hardened criminal fresh out of the joint takes a job as a handyman in a dilapidated house; but the twisted horrors he finds inside are enough to send anyone running. So why does he stay? And why are so many people drawn to Penance Lane?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Scout Taylor-ComptonSherry | Sherry |
 Tyler ManeCrimson Matthews | Crimson Matthews |
 John SchneiderFather John | Father John |
 Daniel RoebuckSheriff Denny Wilson | Sheriff Denny Wilson |
 Dallas PageHyson | Hyson |
 Sailor LarocqueChristina | Christina |
 Troy BrennaDuke | Duke |
 T. LoveBobby | Bobby |
 William TokarskyCrazy Ray | Crazy Ray |
 Booker Huffman, Jr.Shooter | Shooter |
| RRenae GeerlingsPrecious | Precious |
 April BogenschutzJan Roddick | Jan Roddick |
 Michael LeavyTony | Tony |
| TThomas Joseph CullerNoah | Noah |
| JJosh MuellerTrey | Trey |
| LLoren DennisRick | Rick |
| HHarley BurksJoe | Joe |
| TTim D. WelchRocky | Rocky |
 Robert PriviteraTommy | Tommy |
| EElle GeerlingsElle Hoffer | Elle Hoffer |
| GGavin GoodellSuit 2 | Suit 2 |