When Nicky finds an unopened Christmas card from a high school secret admirer, she and her best friend Simone search to find and thank the anonymous author.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Alison SweeneyNicky | Nicky |
 Erica DuranceSimone | Simone |
 Brennan ElliottDerrick | Derrick |
 Michael Karl RichardsJeremy | Jeremy |
| CCatherine BarrollMiriam | Miriam |
 Glen GordonAnthony | Anthony |
 Iris QuinnLinda | Linda |
 Fred HendersonDave | Dave |
 Linda KoElaine | Elaine |
 Patrick RinehartReggie | Reggie |
| SShadan Saul GuerreroElvira | Elvira |
 Tiffani TimmsYvette | Yvette |
 Jarrod EvanyshynRichard | Richard |
 Miguel CastilloTreyton | Treyton |
 Alice ComerChloe | Chloe |