Maggie Chalke is torn between her journalistic integrity and helping her long time crush Mitch O'Grady when her boss orders her to write a story for the paper about the Secret Santa gifts she's been sending Mitch to help him relearn his love for Christmas.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Brooke NevinMaggie Chalke | Maggie Chalke |
 Robin DunneMitch O'Grady | Mitch O'Grady |
 Dani KindGrace | Grace |
 Geri HallRita | Rita |
 A.C. PetersonAlan Kramer | Alan Kramer |
 Greg HovanessianJimmy | Jimmy |
 Tess DegensteinBrianna | Brianna |
 Scott CavalheiroRyan Gallagher | Ryan Gallagher |
 Daniel KashJohn MacDonald | John MacDonald |
| DDon AllisonPeter O'Grady | Peter O'Grady |