NXT Takeover: Fatal 4-Way took place on September 11, 2014. WWE had also advertised for KENTA's debut at the event. KENTA changed his name to Hideo Itami during his debut.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Benjamin SatterlyAdrian Neville | Adrian Neville |
 Rami SebeiSami Zayn | Sami Zayn |
 Mattias ClementTyler Breeze | Tyler Breeze |
 T.J. WilsonTyson Kidd | Tyson Kidd |
 Kenta KobayashiHideo Itami | Hideo Itami |
 Ashley FliehrCharlotte | Charlotte |
 Pam MartinezBayley | Bayley |
 James SmithBull Dempsey | Bull Dempsey |
 Dean MuhtadiMojo Rawley | Mojo Rawley |
 Eric ArndtEnzo Amore | Enzo Amore |
 Thomas La RuffaSylvester Lefort | Sylvester Lefort |
 Thomas PestockBaron Corbin | Baron Corbin |
 Joseph RobinsonCJ Parker | CJ Parker |
 Ryan ParmeterKonnor | Konnor |
 Eric ThompsonViktor | Viktor |
 José RodríguezSin Cara | Sin Cara |
 Emanuel RodriguezKalisto | Kalisto |
 Mikael ViergeMarcus Louis | Marcus Louis |