A bureaucrat interviews five souls to decide which of them will be given a life on Earth. But he soon faces an existential challenge of his own.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Winston DukeWill | Will |
 Zazie BeetzEmma | Emma |
 Benedict WongKyo | Kyo |
 David RysdahlMike | Mike |
 Arianna OrtizMaria | Maria |
 Tony HaleAlexander | Alexander |
 Bill SkarsgårdKane | Kane |
 Perry SmithAnne | Anne |
 Geraldine HughesColleen | Colleen |
| BBrandy PitcherAmanda's Mom | Amanda's Mom |
| EEric RamaekersAmanda's Dad | Amanda's Dad |
| EEliza de Azevedo BrownAmanda (8 years old) | Amanda (8 years old) |
 Lisa StarrettAmanda | Amanda |
 Jeffrey HansonConductor | Conductor |
| EElizaveta ShaikhulinaViolinist | Violinist |
| TTaran MarshallBully | Bully |
| CCaleb FralickBully 2 | Bully 2 |
 Sterlin EnglishRick (14 Years Old) | Rick (14 Years Old) |
| EErika VasquezLuiza | Luiza |
| AAlvaro CortezFernando | Fernando |
 Cherie JulanderAunt / Cecily's Mom | Aunt / Cecily's Mom |
| AAmy BrownCandidate 1 | Candidate 1 |
 David H. StevensCandidate 2 | Candidate 2 |
| AAnthony LegerCandidate 3 | Candidate 3 |
| LLiliana ArredondoOfficer 2 | Officer 2 |
 Victor MedinaOfficer 3 | Officer 3 |
 Bryce FerneliusOfficer 1 | Officer 1 |
 Jemesa SnukaFugitive | Fugitive |
| TTony RivasPriest Officiant | Priest Officiant |