 Bill MoseleyAri Hall | Ari Hall |
 Kimberly HamiltonMaia | Maia |
 LaKesha LoreneBrenda | Brenda |
 Jason CroweClint (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | Clint (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
 Jeff PearsonKarl (“Land Grab” Section) | Karl (“Land Grab” Section) |
| DDominick WilkinsLeo (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | Leo (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
 Brittany Rachelle SmithNatalie (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | Natalie (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
| JJenna RuizGinnie (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | Ginnie (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
| BBailey McBrideSarah (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | Sarah (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
| JJason SmitherJohn (“Gruenwald House” Segment) | John (“Gruenwald House” Segment) |
| DDavid CyborskiDeputy 1 (“Land Grab” & “Gruenwald House” Segments) | Deputy 1 (“Land Grab” & “Gruenwald House” Segments) |
| SScott BlakeHillbilly Monster / Creature in the Woods | Hillbilly Monster / Creature in the Woods |
| TTopher ChambersUber Driver (“Land Grab” Segment) | Uber Driver (“Land Grab” Segment) |
| SSteven DurgarnGary Wilhoite (“Land Grab” Segment) | Gary Wilhoite (“Land Grab” Segment) |
| KKyle PutraMissing YouTuber (“Land Grab” Segment) | Missing YouTuber (“Land Grab” Segment) |
| BBrandon BenzDeputy 2 | Deputy 2 |
| MMichael R. HolfordCo-Worker ("Back Country" Segment) | Co-Worker ("Back Country" Segment) |
| RRyan DaffornCaller #3 (voice) | Caller #3 (voice) |
| CChris MakerChris ("Back Country" Segment) | Chris ("Back Country" Segment) |
| WWhitney McClimansCo-Worker 2 ("Back Country" Segment) | Co-Worker 2 ("Back Country" Segment) |
| SStephanie RileyTammy (Land Grab Section) | Tammy (Land Grab Section) |
| CCJ SanfordCheif Richardson (Land Grab, Gruenwald House Segments) | Cheif Richardson (Land Grab, Gruenwald House Segments) |
| KKyle SarjentCaller #1 | Caller #1 |
