Naughty But Nice was based on The Bigamists, a story by Lewis Alen Brown. Gawky country girl Berenice Summers (Colleen Moore) is catapulted head-first into High Society when her Uncle Seth (Burr McIntosh) strikes oil. Shipped off to a fancy boarding school, Berenice suffers at the hands of her snooty classmates, but the last straw comes when she's publicly humiliated by local wise-guy Paul Carroll (Donald Reed).
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Colleen MooreBernice Sumners | Bernice Sumners |
 Donald ReedPaul Carroll | Paul Carroll |
 Claude GillingwaterJudge J. R. Altewood | Judge J. R. Altewood |
 Kathryn McGuireAlice Altewood | Alice Altewood |
 Hallam CooleyRalph Ames | Ralph Ames |
 Edythe ChapmanMrs. Altewood | Mrs. Altewood |
 Clarissa SelwynneMiss Perkins | Miss Perkins |
 Burr McIntoshUncle Seth Sumners | Uncle Seth Sumners |
 Loretta Young(uncredited) | (uncredited) |