A woman is told by a gypsy that she'll fall in love with a man named John. So her friends turn her life upside down to help her date every John they collectively know to find the "one".
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Andriana ManfrediAli | Ali |
 Ross JirglSean | Sean |
| JJess DelVizoBrooke | Brooke |
 Shae RobinsHelen | Helen |
 Demetrius DanielsMike | Mike |
| DDan FowlksDr. John | Dr. John |
 Charla BocchicchioMadame Zoe | Madame Zoe |
| TTrenton JamesChef John | Chef John |
 D.L. WalkerLandlord Steve | Landlord Steve |
 Manning HazenJohn Kimball | John Kimball |
 Charan PrabhakarTalker John | Talker John |
 Jonny SwensonHandsome John | Handsome John |
 Casey ElliottBrian | Brian |
| WWeston WrightFair Worker | Fair Worker |