Set on Fire Island, My Hustler depicts competition over the affections of a young male hustler among a straight woman, a former male hustler, and the man who hired the boy's companionship via a "Dial-A-Hustler" service.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Paul AmericaPaul | Paul |
| JJoseph CampbellJoe | Joe |
| GGenevieve CharbonGenevieve | Genevieve |
 Dorothy DeanWoman with Lipstick | Woman with Lipstick |
| EEd HoodEd | Ed |
| JJ.D. McDermottKali | Kali |