Maggie is horrified to meet a woman who also claims to be married to her husband, Alan. Adversaries at first, they soon uncover a web of lies surrounding Alan and the many wives he's bilked before.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kristi MurdockMaggie | Maggie |
 Christina LicciardiPam | Pam |
 K.J. BakerKatie | Katie |
| CCat BorovickaOfficer Novak | Officer Novak |
 Nathan LeeMax | Max |
| AAdam HarperAlan | Alan |
 Bonny BreuerSelma | Selma |
 Kylie DelreKristin | Kristin |
| BBryan FrankBarry | Barry |
| AAmanda Rosario GlassAdrian | Adrian |
 Brendan GoshayCurtis | Curtis |
| CCody KahakuEthan | Ethan |
| JJoseph MazzaPete | Pete |
| LLaTrallo PresleyBuddy | Buddy |
| MMarilyn LightLois | Lois |
 Kayla GibsonNew Wife | New Wife |
 Adam HarperAlan | Alan |