In this sequel, the daughters' anniversary present is the news that their widowed father is about to get remarried.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Robert YoungJudge Charles Raleigh | Judge Charles Raleigh |
 Ruth HusseyMaggie Cartwright | Maggie Cartwright |
 Raymond MasseyMatthew Cunningham | Matthew Cunningham |
 Sharon GlessJennifer | Jennifer |
 Lara ParkerCharlotte | Charlotte |
 Darleen CarrSusan | Susan |
 Anna LeeJudge Barbara Hanline | Judge Barbara Hanline |
 Darrell LarsonAndy O'Brien | Andy O'Brien |
 Judy StrangisRobin | Robin |
 Colby ChesterBrad Coombs | Brad Coombs |
 Jerry FogelJerry Greene | Jerry Greene |
 Lois JanuaryNurse | Nurse |