Shortly after high school student Jeremy Capello goes on a hot date, he finds he can't stand garlic or see his reflection in mirrors.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Robert Sean LeonardJeremy Capello | Jeremy Capello |
 Evan MirandRalph | Ralph |
 Leeanne Locken EmberlinCandy Andrews | Candy Andrews |
 Cheryl PollakDarla Blake | Darla Blake |
 Cecilia PeckNora | Nora |
 Fannie FlaggMrs. Capello | Mrs. Capello |
 Kenneth KimminsMr. Capello | Mr. Capello |
 David WarnerProfessor Leopold McCarthy | Professor Leopold McCarthy |
 Paul WillsonGrimsdyke | Grimsdyke |
 René AuberjonoisModoc | Modoc |
| MMichelle La VigneFlo | Flo |
| HHarvey ChristiansenGeorge | George |
| EErica ZeitlinGloria | Gloria |
| GGary ChasonDrivers Ed Instructor | Drivers Ed Instructor |
 Kathy BatesHelen Blake | Helen Blake |
 John ChappellBuddy Blake | Buddy Blake |
| JJill BianchiniWaitress | Waitress |
| JJ.P. ConroyButcher | Butcher |
 Amelia KinkadeBrunette in Punk Bar | Brunette in Punk Bar |
| EE. Linda MooreGirl at Bar | Girl at Bar |
| MMarianne SimpsonBlonde in Punk Bar | Blonde in Punk Bar |
| SStaness JonekosRedhead in Punk Bar | Redhead in Punk Bar |
 Ronnie Rondell Jr.Bouncer | Bouncer |
| CChris WycliffPolice Officer #1 | Police Officer #1 |
 Coy SevierPolice Officer #2 | Police Officer #2 |